Paul Roblin on Dobson et al’s Lancet Tamiflu re-analysis: an independent review group. Really?

On 30 January 2015 the Lancet published a re-analysis of oseltamivir effects in symptomatic influenza like illness “Oseltamivir treatment for influenza in adults: a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials.” This was authored by Joanna Dobson, Richard J Whitley, Stuart Pocock, and Arnold S Monto. The Lancet supplemented this re-analysis with an article by Heath Kelly and Benjamin […]

Read More…

The challenges China faces as it stops using organs from executed prisoners

From 1 January 2015, China stopped using organs from executed prisoners for transplants. This was announced by Jiefu Huang, China’s former vice minister of health and current head of the Organ Donation Committee. This comes after a series of legislative frameworks for organ donation and transplantation since 2007, as well as several pilot programmes that were conducted between […]

Read More…

Kate Adlington: Mitochondrial donation—the person at the centre of “three person IVF”

A vote was held yesterday in the House of Commons to decide whether to allow mitochondrial donation to be used in clinical practice. The vote marked the culmination of a decade of research and consultation into the science and ethics of so called “three person IVF”—a modified IVF technique proposed to prevent transmission of mitochondrial […]

Read More…

Pritpal S Tamber: Interview with Jonathan Stead on transforming disadvantaged communities

It’s pretty well understood that people from disadvantaged communities have more important things to worry about than their health. However, one general practitioner (primary care physician) in the southwest of England believes that if you start from what people actually want, you can eventually impact their health and wellbeing. That general practitioner is Dr Jonathan […]

Read More…

The BMJ Today: Torture, training, and role models

Unsettlingly recent media coverage seems to be full of articles and images of torture which raises the questions for our profession of “What is the role of doctors when faced with victims of torture?” and “Where should their loyalties lie?” Torture as described in a recent editorial is “a complex, politically driven phenomenon that is […]

Read More…

Neville Goodman: Stemming the rising tide of epidemic proportions

Metaphor is useful. When Malcolm Gladwell wrote about an epidemic of Hush Puppies, no one thought that Hush Puppies were transmissible in anything more than the metaphorical sense. But as doctors we need to be more careful before we muddy the meanings of our technical words. An epidemic is a widespread occurrence of an infectious […]

Read More…

The BMJ Today: When is a doctor a GMC doctor and when is a doctor a Robodoc?

Plans to move doctors’ full registration with the General Medical Council from the end of the first year of foundation training to the point of graduation from medical school was first mooted over a year ago in a major review of postgraduate medical education and training. The plan was voted down at the BMA’s annual […]

Read More…

James Buchanan: Genomics, the data revolution, and health economics—the 2015 Astellas Innovation Debate

It’s early days, but 2015 is already shaping up to be another exciting year for researchers in genomics. In his State of the Union address last month, Barack Obama launched a new $215m Precision Medicine Initiative, which aims to collect genomic sequencing data for one million individuals. In the UK, we’re slightly further down this […]

Read More…