James Raftery: The NHS top-up policy for drugs not recommended by NICE – challenging the limits?

A recent breakfast meeting at the Kings Fund discussed the issue of an NHS top-up policy in relation to multifocal lenses in cataract surgery. My contribution from the commissioner perspective involved six points: i) the lenses were dear, adding several hundred pounds to the around £800 NHS cost of a cataract procedure, ii) that they were highly […]

Read More…

Richard Smith: In the goldfish bowl with GPs

Two weeks ago I spent 90 minutes in a goldfish bowl with about 30 GPs. The goldfish bowl is a process to encourage reflection, and it certainly caused me to reflect. The goldfish bowl features in the leadership course of the Royal General College of Practitioners. Somebody with some pretensions to having been a leader […]

Read More…

Tiago Villanueva: My early thoughts on professional development after vocational training

One of the purposes of vocational training is to develop good professional development habits and skills that will hopefully be sustained and honed throughout the rest of a doctor’s professional life. The great thing about completing vocational training and entering the ranks of seniority is not having to feel forced to study periodically and carry […]

Read More…

Richard Smith: A short history of patient power

I urge you to read Michael Millenson’s article on “Spock, Feminists, and the Fight for Participatory Medicine: a History.” It’s a fascinating and very readable account of how patient power has steadily increased in the US, and it would be very good to have a similar history in Britain. Most of what follows in this […]

Read More…

Liz Wager: How should editors respond to plagiarism?

Gross plagiarism is easy to spot and most people agree it’s wrong, so it’s relatively easy to deal with. But while stealing somebody else’s paper and pretending it’s your own is obvious misconduct, it’s surprisingly hard to define exactly what plagiarism is, especially for more minor offences. It would be helpful if we could agree […]

Read More…