Richard Lehman’s journal review—1 October 2012

Arch Intern Med  24 Sep 2012  Vol 172 Of Exercise I sing, and that benignant sweat Which from six thousand diabetic brows Exudes. My pen, Hygeia, speed! To save That honey-urined tribe from mortal pains Which Indolence doth breed, and glut of food: That to the treadmill they may go, or healthful jog, Or bicycle […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review—24 September 2012

JAMA  19 Sep 2012  Vol 308 1122    This week’s JAMA is devoted to obesity. It’s a bit like global warming: we can see it happening around us, we can foresee terrible consequences, we pretend to ourselves we’re doing something about it, but we know that in the end only drastic solutions will work, and these […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review—17 September 2012

JAMA  12 Sep 2012  Vol 308 981    “Considering the cost, invasiveness, inpatient requirement, and morbidity of bariatric surgery, a truly intensive nonsurgical comparison group is not only justifiable but also necessary to avoid scientific bias. A suitably intensive lifestyle intervention should include multiple components, such as residential treatment for several weeks to initiate rapid weight […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review – 10 September 2012

JAMA  5 Sep 2012  Vol 308 869    Cancer, multiple sclerosis, stroke: do you want your patients to get the benefit of new drugs for these conditions as soon as possible? It’s pretty hard to say no to a question like that, but if you follow the flow of this rhetoric you can easily ignore poor […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review—3 September 2012

NEJM  30 Aug 2012  Vol 367 787   Most medical research is boring and irrelevant. We take that for granted: most clinicians only read research papers if they urgently need to, and then usually fail to discover what they were looking for. The corollary is that most of the effort of medical academia is futile, and […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review—20 August 2012

JAMA  15 Aug 2012  Vol 308 681   From time to time, most of the medical journals are seized with a worthy impulse to discuss violence. One of its commonest and most ubiquitous forms is intimate partner violence, most of which goes undetected. Occasionally it is first disclosed in the course of a medical consultation, and […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review—13 August 2012

JAMA  8 Aug 2012  Vol 308 575    When Stephen Lock was editor of the BMJ, he banned the expression “further research is needed” on the grounds that further research is always needed. Here is a piece by John Oiannidis which argues that further research is very often badly needed—and that it is very often instantly […]

Read More…

Richard Lehman’s journal review – 30 July 2012

JAMA  25 July 2012  Vol 308 This was the week of the XIX International AIDS Conference held in Washington DC, where the catchphrase everywhere was “an AIDS-free generation.” That forms the title of the first piece in this week’s JAMA, which is given over entirely to HIV-related matters. So also is a large part of […]

Read More…